« The British have all the best ads. | Main | On this day in history: »

March 04, 2006

The thought that keeps me up at night

Is That Legal?: "The Idea of Doing Nothing"

How are Americans in 2006 different from Germans in 1936? It isn’t our biology, which means that Americans are perfectly capable of exterminating a whole culture or people. The only thing which prevents us from doing so is our institutions. Paper, and the respect we give to that paper, seem a slim reed on which to place our prayers. It’s the only thing humanity has ever had...

And yet that respect for paper as failed, in the past:

He had not heard of it before, and, when I told him of the West Coast Army Commander's statement that "a Jap is a Jap," he hit the table with his fist and said, "Right you are. A Jap is a Jap, a Jew is a Jew." "A German is a German," I said. "Of course," said the German proudly. "It's a matter of blood."

He asked me whether I had known anybody connected with the West Coast deportation. When I said "no," he asked me what I had done about it. When I said "Nothing," he said, triumphantly, "There. You learned about all these things openly, through your government and your press. We did not learn through ours. As in your case, nothing was required of us--in our case, not even knowledge. You knew about things you thought were wrong -- you did think it was wrong, didn't you, Herr Professor?" "Yes." "So. You did nothing. So it is everywhere." When I protested that the Japanese-descended Americans had not been treated like the Jews, he said, "And if they had been -- what then? Do you not se that the idea of doing something or doing nothing is in either case the same?"

America has, in the past, done horrible things to our own citizens. We must be ever vigilant against doing so in the future...

Posted by Andrew at March 4, 2006 01:01 AM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.punningpundit.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/929

Comments